How three school districts are defying state restrictions on mask mandates
But some school districts have taken more methodical approaches, carefully bypassing state restrictions on mask requirements through cautious legal maneuvering or apparent loopholes.
Here’s how three school districts are defying state restrictions on mask mandates.
Texas school district changed dress code
In a statement, the board of directors of ISD in Paris said it made the decision because it was “concerned about the health and safety of its students and employees.”
“The council believes the dress code can be used to alleviate communicable health concerns, and has therefore changed the PISD dress code to protect our students and employees,” the statement said. “The governor of Texas does not have the power to usurp the exclusive power and duty of the board of trustees to govern and oversee the management of public schools in the district.”
Additionally, after Thursday’s ruling, the Texas Education Agency issued guidelines saying it would not enforce restrictions on mask warrants while the executive order litigation is ongoing.
Dennis Eichelbaum, general counsel of Paris ISD, has been advising school boards for more than a year to add masks to their dress code, he told CNN. So when Paris ISD asked if they could impose masks, he told them they had “one hundred percent authority over their dress code.”
“That’s where it actually belongs,” he said. “The obligation to wear masks is really no different from the obligation to wear shoes or other protective equipment that we need.”
The measure is not a “loophole,” Eichelbaum said, because the executive order did not suspend the Texas Education Code, which gives the school board the power to govern schools in the district.
âIt just falls under that,â Eichelbaum said, âand because the governor never suspended this, we are allowed to do anything within these parameters, which are quite broad.â
Eichelbaum wouldn’t be surprised if a challenge arose in the future, depending on how the other cases go, he says. For now, if Texas school districts want to implement mask mandates, he thinks the best choice is to include masks in their dress codes.
Oklahoma City Public Schools Bypass School Board
But that hasn’t stopped several districts from demanding masks, including Oklahoma City public schools.
Parents are allowed to request a waiver for medical, religious or personal reasons, the letter said. But according to OKCPS, Wednesday, only 94 students out of about 30,000 – less than 1% – had withdrawn. Families have until September 10 to apply for the exemption.
Crystal Raymond, spokesperson for the district, told CNN that the district announced the mask requirement after the number of reported cases in the district among students and staff rose from three digits over the course of of the first three days of school.
âThis told us that the mitigation strategies in place weren’t enough,â Raymond said in an email.
The response from parents and staff “has been overwhelmingly positive and the majority of our students and staff have complied,” she said.
OKCPS isn’t alone: ââSanta Fe South Schools, a public charter school district in the area, said earlier this month they would require masks, but also included a opt-out provision.
The governor’s office said it had no issues with the OKCPS and Santa Fe South requirements as they provide the option to opt out. Spokeswoman Carly Atchison told CNN in a statement, “As long as the kids have the opportunity to spend five days a week in person and as long as the parents have a choice, the governor has no problem.”
âSchool districts can use magic words as much as they want,â Atchison added, âbut as soon as they take away choices from parents, that’s when they break the law.â
But the district’s letter to families says those who wished to opt out could switch to the district’s virtual learning option, angering the state’s governor and attorney general.
In his statement to CNN, Atchison noted that SB 658 “was passed with the support of 80% of the legislature and the governor will enforce the law in the state of Oklahoma.”
Neither Santa Fe South Public Schools nor Hulbert responded to CNN’s requests for comment.
Court rules Arizona district can impose masks – for now
The Phoenix Union High School District in Arizona has at least purchased its mask requirement for some time.
But a Maricopa County judge ruled this week that the law has yet to come into force, despite a retroactivity clause saying the law will come into effect on June 30. the session ends on September 29.
What happens after that date is an open question, District Attorney Mary O’Grady told CNN, noting that there was a separate lawsuit challenging the constitutionality of the legislation.
The judge also did not dismiss the lawsuit against Phoenix Union High School, giving the complainant an opportunity to modify the complaint.
Meanwhile, the Phoenix Union High School District has “received overwhelming support from our students and families,” district spokesperson Richard Franco told CNN.
âParents and students have told us that they understand why we are demanding masks, and they are very grateful,â he said. “No one likes to wear a mask, but our community postal codes remain among the hardest hit by COVID-19, and our community understands that we must do all we can to mitigate the spread of the virus.”
When asked if the district would continue to enforce the mandate after September 29, Franco acknowledged that a lot “can and will change by the end of September with the virus, the guidelines and even potentially the law.”
âWe don’t know what the future holds,â he said, âbut we will remain committed to protecting the health and safety of our staff, students, families and the community within the meaning large”.